Assistance to detainees: +34 699 241 599

Criminal law

Shareholder disputes and director liability

Published on September 22nd, 2026

A dispute between shareholders usually starts on civil ground, with a resolution that disadvantages part of the shareholders or a director's decision that damages the company's assets. A third element often joins in, a transaction that was never put to the shareholders' meeting. What many miss, especially when the amount at stake is high, is that the same conduct can carry a criminal dimension too and that pursuing it down only one track risks losing rights on the other that cannot be recovered later.

Corporate and individual claims

Spain's Companies Act divides the claims against a director according to who was harmed by the act.

The first protects the company's assets and the second one's own, and in practice that distinction often decides which route is even open, sometimes both.

The criminal side of the dispute

Not every damaging decision by a director is a crime, and the line rarely sits where the loss is largest. Spain's Criminal Code (Código Penal) sets out several offenses that come up regularly in a shareholder dispute:

What separates these offenses from a bad business call is the conduct more than the outcome, that is, whether powers were exceeded and whether the end result was a benefit taken at someone else's expense.

According to the Audiencia Nacional (Spain's national criminal court, judgment 10/2026 of April 20th), a director who takes part in an abusive resolution without objecting can be held liable as a necessary participant (cooperador necesario), but not one who has a clear and reasoned objection entered in the minutes.

The business judgment rule

The same law protects, the other way round, a director who does the job properly. Article 226 of the Companies Act treats the standard of care of an ordinary businessperson as met when a decision was taken in good faith, without personal interest, on sufficient information and through an adequate procedure. That protection expressly does not extend to decisions affecting other directors, or people connected to them, personally.

That cuts both ways in a shareholder dispute, since a director's defense rarely lies in the outcome of the decision but in the record of how it was made. A shareholder who suspects a breach needs to secure exactly those records before deadlines or retention policies put them out of reach.

Both fronts from the start

Civil and criminal proceedings over the same facts do not run independently, and Spanish law sets out how they interact. Once criminal proceedings are under way, no civil action on the same facts may continue, and a pending one is stayed until the criminal judgment becomes final (article 114 of the Criminal Procedure Act, LECrim). The Civil Procedure Act governs when the civil case is actually stayed, which as a rule happens only once it is ready for judgment and the criminal ruling could be decisive, or immediately if the forgery of a decisive document filed in the case is under criminal investigation (article 40 of the Civil Procedure Act, LEC).

In practice, a criminal complaint (querella) does not by itself bring the civil case to a halt. The judge stays it only if the criminal ruling could be decisive for what the civil court has to decide, the party asking for the stay must show that the criminal case concerns the same facts, and if that case has already been closed there is nothing left to stay (Spanish Supreme Court, judgment 1392/2026 of September 9th). On that reasoning the Barcelona Provincial Court refused to stay a case over a complaint filed by the defendant himself that decided nothing the civil court had to rule on (judgment 375/2026 of May 14th).

Corporate offenses, which include falsifying the accounts and forcing through abusive resolutions, can only be prosecuted on a complaint by the injured party, unless the conduct affects the general interest or a plurality of people (article 296 of the Criminal Code). Breach of fiduciary duty is not subject to that limit. For abusive resolutions, the injured party is whoever was a shareholder when the resolution was forced through, and the High Court of Justice of Galicia went as far as questioning the standing of a company that had bought the shares afterwards (judgment 96/2026 of July 21st).

On the civil track, which has its own clock as well, both the corporate and the individual claim against directors are time-barred four years after the day they could first have been brought (article 241 bis of the Companies Act). Which route to take first, and how to combine them, is therefore a strategic call rather than a purely procedural one. It shapes the burden of proof, the deadlines and the negotiating position, and what is argued in one set of proceedings can be used in the other.

After a final criminal acquittal, the civil judge has to accept the facts found proven or explain why they see them differently (Barcelona Provincial Court, judgment 540/2026 of July 2nd), and in the Galician case it was a final commercial court judgment on the same resolutions that weighed in the directors' acquittal. Whoever reaches judgment first usually fixes the facts for the other proceedings, which is why the order in which the two tracks are pursued is not neutral.

How I approach it

I start by placing the facts on both tracks at once, asking which civil claim fits, whether any of the conduct could carry criminal weight and in what order or combination the two serve the case best. Then come the records: minutes of the shareholders' meeting, board resolutions, annual accounts, correspondence around the disputed decision. I act for shareholders alleging a breach and for directors defending against that claim. This is where my practice in white-collar crime meets company law, and how I work is set out under method. Alongside this matter there often runs the criminal liability of company directors, and when the company is also in financial distress, business distress and insolvency. If criminal proceedings are already under way in Barcelona, you can read how I work as an English-speaking criminal lawyer.

Editorial responsibility: Carles Jiménez, Spanish lawyer (Barcelona Bar No. 34.946). This note was prepared with the assistance of artificial-intelligence tools and reviewed and approved by the author before publication.

Back to the guides

Let's talk about your case

Tell me about your situation and I will tell you, frankly, how I can help.

Get in touch